Economic Survey 2020-21 tries to defend govt policies; says farm sector ‘reforms’ in India were overdue

The Economic Survey 2020-21 has projected India’s GDP to contract by 7.7 per cent, a great fall from the projected 11.5 per cent growth over the revised estimated a year before. Though the survey tries to instil hope in the people by giving all sort of logic, but all are in a defensive vein as against the last years’ economic survey which that was built around India’s aspiration of becoming $5 trillion economy by 2025.

However, the Survey estimates real GDP growth for the next fiscal 2021-22 at 11 per cent only 0.5 per cent less than what was budgeted for the current fiscal. The survey foresees V-shaped economic recovery supported by mega vaccination drive, and endeavours to provide intellectual anchor to the Union government to be more relaxed about debt and fiscal spending during growth slowdown. It calls for more active, counter cyclical fiscal policies, and emphasizes that the situation is “not a call for fiscal irresponsibility”.

The Survey has come at a time when COVID-19 pandemic has hit all the sectors of the economy in 2020, and the worst hit sectors were contact based services, manufacturing and construction, and only sector that shows a silver lining is agriculture. Current account surplus is also expected at 2 per cent of the GDP. Government consumption and net exports have also cushioned growth from diving further.

The contraction estimated by the survey is exactly what the CS0 had estimated earlier as against the RBI’s estimate of 7.5 per cent. It may also be mentioned here that the RBI has forecast that the first half of 2021-22 may witness a real GDP growth of 14.2 per cent.

Many of us might be remembering how the international credit rating organizations had been lowering the credit worthiness of India in the recent past. The Survey strongly refutes them by stating that India’s sovereign credit rating doesn’t reflect its fundamentals.

“Never in the history of sovereign credit ratings has the 5th largest economy been rated as the lowest rung of investment grade (BBB -). India’s fiscal policy must not remain beholden to a noisy, biased measure of India’s fundamentals. India’s forex reserves can cover an additional 2.8 standard deviation negative event. It is imperative that sovereign credit rating methodology be made more transparent, less subjective,” the document emphasizes.

The logic is clearly aimed at the critics of the performance of the Modi government, which has been very poor for years, and coupled with mismanagement of finance and policy experiments, had caused a serious downturn in the economy even before the breakout of the pandemic. It was in very bad shape. GDP growth rate had fallen to a decade low to 4.9, and unemployment rate to over 6 per cent at 45 years high. Then came the pandemic and our economy severely impacted which is reflected by the Survey report.

The Survey tries its best to put the blame for badly performing economy entirely on the pandemic and tries to protect the government by telling us that the contraction was pandemic-driven. India will grow now in 2021-22 at the rate of 11 per cent of the GDP and the nominal GDP will grow by 15.4 per cent.

India must continue to focus on economic growth to lift the poor out of poverty by expanding the overall pie, the report says, which is indeed an indirect acceptance that the government has not been doing what was actually needed. However, it says that such a work is possible only when “the size of the economic pie grows”. It emphasized the redistributive objectives while calling for “policy focus”.

It has been noted in the Survey that healthcare has finally taken the center stage. The report states that this path would entail a growth in real GDP by 2.4 per cent over the absolute level of 2019-20. It implies that the economy would take two years to reach the pre-pandemic level; however, the government would need to play a key role to shape the structure of the healthcare market, it has been observed.

Softening of CPI recently reflects easing of supply side constraints that affected food inflation, the report has emphasized. It has been predicted that air passenger travel and aircraft movements would reach pre-Covid level in early 2021. Private trains may be introduced in 2023-24, bidding process for which is expected to be completed by May 2021. There are several other things that create a rosy picture.

The Survey gives a very significant warning on the banking sector risks that the country has been facing for quite some time now. It calls for adequate capitalization of public sector banks, or else lenders may resort to risk-shifting, the report warns, severely impacting the real economic recovery.

“Under-capitalised banks may again resort to risk-shifting and zombie lending, thereby severely exacerbating the problem. The adverse impact could then spill over to the real economy through good borrowers and projects being denied credit. The resultant drop in the investment rate of the economy could then lead to the slowdown of economic growth,” it said.

It may be mentioned here that credit growth is at a record low level, stifling the growth of business and industry. The observation is also important because our industries and business, especially MSMEs, need more money in loan and incentives to overcome the crisis they have been facing. Many of them are just struggling to survive.

While dealing with the agriculture sector, the survey says that farm sector reforms in India were overdue and would help create “One India, One Market”. It says that reforms would offer more opportunities to farmers. The observation is significant indicating that government is not willing to scrap the three farm laws that the agitating farmers have been demanding, though the government was lately reported to have been willing to put them on hold for one and half years. It has been noted that only agriculture contributed to positive growth while service and industry contributed to the contraction in GDP.

The Survey indicates faster normalization of the economy with gradual lifting of restriction. It anticipates faster than anticipated economic recovery over the second half of 2021-22.

(IPA Service)