MP: 1,000 intellectuals protest withdrawal of permission to organise international webinar by Sagar Univ

A statement has been signed by close to 1000 individuals from across India and other countries including scientists, academics from all prominent universities in India and abroad over the withdrawal of permission to organise ‘International Webinar on Cultural and Linguistic Hurdles in the Achievement of Scientific Temper’. These individuals also include artists, lawyers, retired bureaucrats, activists, filmmakers, engineers, students & other concerned citizens, including A C Michael, United Christian Forum, Former Member of Delhi Minorities Commission, New Delhi, A J Jawad, Independent, Lawyer, Chennai, Abdul Hafiz Lakhani, Editor Siyasat dot net, Journalism, Ahmadabad. All the academics and well-known intellectuals have shown displeasure at the way the permission was withdrawn. Calling it an attack on the scientific temper, the statement says, "The atrocious argument that someone’s feelings will get hurt if ‘hurdles in achieving scientific temper’ are discussed by academicians and scholars is only a smoke screen to intimidate free speech and academic discourse."

The complete text of the statement can be read here:

We the concerned citizens, academicians, scientists, writers, activists , concerned citizens learned through the disturbing media report that at the behest of the ABVP, the Central University of Doctor Harisingh Gour Vishwavidya, Sagar withdrew permission to organize ‘International Webinar on Cultural and Linguistic Hurdles in the Achievement of Scientific Temper’. We are deeply alarmed by the reported sequence of events.

1. The Department of Anthropology, Dr. Harisingh Gour Vishwavidyalaya, in collaboration with Montclair State University, New Jersey, USA decided to host the above online seminar in early May, 2021. Departmental council of the Department of Anthropology passed a resolution to organize an International Webinar with collaboration of GIAN Faculty Prof. Neeraj Vedwan, Montclair State University, USA on 28 May 2021.

2. The proposal was sent to the Vice Chancellor on 2 June 2021. It was approved and permission was accorded, on 7 June 2021, by her. Subsequently, the list of speakers, which included the name of Prof. Gauhar Raza and Prof. Apoorvanand was approved by the VC on 20 July 2021.

3. On 22 July 2021, ABVP submitted a memorandum and threaten the university to disrupt the conference unless the names of Prof. Gauhar Raza and Prof. Apoorvanand are not dropped from the list of speakers.

4. On 29 July 2021, the university started buckling under the pressure and the Registrar issued a letter, asking the Head of the Department to seek permission from the Ministry for holding a conference.

5. 29 July 2021. The Police Superintendent who should have provided all the support to the university for organising the conference wrote a threatening letter to VC. Instead of controlling the goons the police threatened to slap 505 IPC on the organisers.

6. On 30 July 2021, the registrar issued another letter to postpone the webinar till approval is granted. And he proactively warned the organisers and participants to refrain even from attending the conference.

7. At the time of the conference police officials and university security staff were deployed in the Department so that nobody could even listen to the proceedings.

We believe that this event represents a twin attack on the scientific temper as well as on the autonomy of the academic institution. Evidently since this government has come to power there has been a relentless assault on both. The atrocious argument that someone’s feelings will get hurt if ‘hurdles in achieving scientific temper’ are discussed by academicians and scholars is only a smoke screen to intimidate free speech and academic discourse.

We are ashamed that this has been allowed to happen in 21st century India. We were the first country to pass a Scientific Policy Resolution, including ‘spreading scientific temper’ as a constitutional duty of every citizen, which we should rightly be proud of. We also believe that this is not an isolated incident, there have been similar attacks on the academicians in Ujjain, Mandsaur, Bhopal in the recent past. However, this incident has surpassed all limits of civility and has also sullied the image of the country abroad.

We are shocked by the letter of the Superintendent of Police, Atul Singh to the Vice-Chancellor which unequivocally threatens the organisers to invoke ‘505 IPC’, against them ‘if any speaker’ hurts the feelings of ‘any group’. Atul Singh is quoted to have said that he had received “references to the past history, anti-national mentality and caste-related statements of the speakers attending the webinar”. It is clear that at the behest of the political masters, the police wanted to scare organisers and force them not to organise the seminar.

We not only condemn the attack on the liberty and freedom of the University, the faculty members and assault on the scientific temper, but also stand by Prof. Apoorvanand, Prof. Gauhar Raza and the faculty members who withstood the pressure.