Modi govt to blame for onion prices bringing tears to farmers’ eyes  

The Narendra Modi government may have promised to double farm incomes by 2022, but farmers in the country's onion-growing regions are appalled at the bizarre market dynamics that keep its retail price hovering between ₹20-30 a kilogram while they struggle to get even 10-20% of the final cost.

The constant fall in prices and subsequent lower remuneration in the past few weeks has led to outbursts and protests where farmers have thrown tonnes of onions on roads, while one farmer made national news by sending his meagre returns to Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Onion farmers blame the government and its arbitrary policies on exports and procurement for their plight.

According to the Food Ministry, on Thursday, onions were sold for ₹27 per kg in Delhi, for ₹22 in Mumbai, for ₹25 in Kolkata and for ₹16 in Chennai. The retail prices were higher by ₹2-5 last week.

At Nashik's Lasalgaon, the country's largest wholesale market for onions, prices for onions harvested in summer have fallen to ₹100-300 per quintal while fresh arrivals have managed to get an average of ₹800-1,000 per quintal.

Notably, the input cost for cultivation of a kilo of onions has been fixed at ₹8.50 by the Directorate of Onion and Garlic Research (DOGR), a constituent body of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR).

Sanjay Sathe, an onion grower from Nashik, came into the limelight a few days ago after he sent a money-order of ₹1,064 to Modi as a mark of protest.

"I did not sell a part of onions I cultivated this summer due to the prevailing low prices. However, I was forced to sell it now as I had no money. I was shocked when I received just ₹1,064 for 750 kg," Sathe said.

"I paid ₹400 to clean those onions and ₹750 for transportation. So what I have been left with in the end? Nothing!"

Aghast at the gloomy side of the market dynamics, Sathe sent the money-order to awaken the government to the situation. Last year, he sold onions at ₹3,000 per quintal. He says the authorities do not have an answer for the sharp slump in prices this year.

Anoop Kumar, Principal Secretary of Maharashtra's Marketing Department, said the onion crop that hits the market in winter has a short shelf life, which may have led to the low procurement price.

"We are aware of the low prices. We have operationalised a scheme to provide 50% subsidy on the transportation if onions are sold in other states," said Kumar.

The situation is similar in other onion-producing states like Madhya Pradesh, Karnataka and Rajasthan.

Farmer activist Kedar Sirohi said the remuneration to onion growers in poll-bound Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan has fallen to as low as ₹1 per kg.

"Due to the advancement in transportation and communication, prices remain more or less the same in the adjoining states. In Neemuch (in Madhya Pradesh), one farmer received just ₹2,300 for 2,100 kg of onion he sold on Wednesday. So, roughly, ₹1 per kg," said Sirohi, who is the president of the Aam Kisan Union.

Lasalgaon APMC Market Chairman Jaydatta Holkar said the government's inconsistent export policies and additional procurement were to be blamed.

"There have been so many flip-flops on the export policies in last few years that we have lost credibility in the international market. There is now greater demand for onions from Pakistan," said Holkar.

"Also, the government procured a huge amount of onions though the NAFED (National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation) last year. It sent a wrong signal in the market that there is no demand," said Holkar.

India exported 24,15,739 tonnes of onions in 2016-17 but this reduced to 15,88,985 tonnes in 2017-18, as per Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA).

Around 8,31,645 tonnes of onions have been exported since April this year.

Holkar asked for an increase in the incentives for onion exports under the Merchandise Export from India Scheme (MEIS) from the current 5% to 10%.

Sathe said he received a call from a Maharashtra government official seeking details about his land and crop yield and if he was a part of any political outfit.

"There was just a phone call. I do not know who it was, except that it was a government official. Nothing has happened since then," he said.

A senior Agriculture Ministry official said cognisance had been taken of the situation but no decision has been taken so far.

The ministry cannot intervene until a state approaches it for implementing the Market Intervention Scheme (MIS), which is designed to protect farmers from making distress sales, said the official, who requested anonymity.