Mahua Moitra’s viral speech in the Lok Sabha on PM CARES: Emperor, where are your clothes?  

The Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation and Amendment of Certain Provisions) Bill, 2020 is deeply problematic because an insidious objective of this Bill is to give a blanket clearance with no accountability whatsoever to the PM CARES Fund.

The origin of this fund is not only steeped in opacity but rips apart the fabric of federalism and is inherently discriminatory in nature. I was among the first petitioners in the Supreme Court against the discriminatory nature of the fund – but the bench in its wisdom, while not dismissing my petition on merits asked me to bring it up in parliament. So here I am, wondering how an issue of constitutionality that should have attracted judicial review is now instead being debated in this august house.

The government issued a circular on March 28, 2020 notifying that all contributions to the PM CARES Fund qualified as eligible CSR expenditure under Item No. (viii) of Schedule VII of the Companies Act, 2013. But it disqualified contributions made to the ‘state relief funds’ from being treated as valid CSR activities, despite the same being expressly permissible under Schedule VII of the Act of 2013. Items (i) and (xii) under Schedule VII specifically permit companies to fund activities pertaining to the promotion of health care and preventive health care and disaster management and relief efforts.

This unequal treatment of the state and central relief funds is in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution. Unfair treatment of identical contributions to the state relief funds is against public interest and public policy. It completely disincentivises corporate contributions which the state governments would have otherwise received. It creates an unfair, unjust and discriminatory distinction against the ‘state’ and ‘chief minister’s relief funds’ in favour of the ‘PM CARES’ Fund, despite both being permissible under the statutory mandate of the Companies Act, 2013.

Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman, while introducing the Bill, read out a long list of schoolchildren and pensioners who readily and happily gave away their meagre savings to the PM CARES fund. But why was the minister silent on the 38 PSUs that have donated more than 2100 Crore Rupees to PM CARES – almost 70% of the total corpus. These are public sector undertakings – share capital subscribed to by the Government of India with the people’s money. Without an audit, the conflict of interest is writ large.

We should also remember that the PMO in response to an application for disclosure of the incorporating documents of the PM CARES trust said that it is not a public authority as far as the RTI is concerned and thus refused to disclose its origins.

The very legislative intent behind Section 135 of the Companies Act, creating CSR, was to encourage companies to commit contributions for public welfare activities locally and in areas where they operate.

The PM CARES diverts those funds away from local communities into a dark hole where not even a speck of light can enter. Coal India has committed 221 Crore Rupees to the fund while it cannot contribute to the state relief funds of Bengal and Jharkhand, which account for all of its business! ONGC has mentioned that it has offered funds from its CSR budget for this year, even though this allocation is “yet to be determined”.

HPCL has admitted to contributing 120 crore rupees from its CSR budget for the ongoing financial year which is yet to be finalised. Power Finance Corporation contributed 200 Crore Rupees even though its entire CSR allocation is only 150 Crore. It is like the courtiers of the emperor competing with one another to give him gifts with public funds.

If these improprieties were not bad, enough please consider the mas sive donations made by Chinese companies. Xiaomi, a Chinese company accused of snooping on users gave PM CARES 10 Crore, TikTok, banned by the Modi government a few weeks ago, gave 30 Crore and Huawei – banned all around the world for its well-documented links to the Chinese Army, donated 10 Crore. Why did the government take this money from India’s enemies? Why doesn’t it return this tainted money?

I am sure no dying Indian would choose to be on a ventilator paid for by Chinese money. The government says it has put Rs 2000 crore towards 50,000 ventilators. It should lay on the table of this House how many ventilators have been physically delivered to which hospitals and in which states. And also disclose the manner of procurement. We hope its friends – who have been buying up our Indian airwaves and airports – have nothing to do with this.

The dangers of these unverified foreign donations are amplified by the fact that the PM CARES fund exempted itself from FCRA regulations even though it does not meet the pre-condition of a body whose funds are audited by the CAG.

There are three takeaways:

First, the Government is raising funds on the basis of public office. The very name – a “Prime Minister’s” fund – makes people think this is a government authority. So, by saying it is not open to RTI, it is running away from the spirit of transparency it should be wedded to.

Second, cabinet members are trustees to administer the funds, so this impermissibly expands the scope of ministerial office in excess of the mandate determined by the Constitution.

Third, it is commandeering resources donations by default. A circular issued by the Department of Revenue under the Ministry of Finance on April 17 to all officers and staff appealing to them to “contribute their one day’s salary every month till March 2021” to the PM CARES Fund. Anyone having any objection has to say so in writing. With the atmosphere of fear and vengeance prevalent in society under this government, which bureaucrat, which public servant will say they do not wish to donate?

In the end, I would like to make three appeals to this government. First, stop lying to us all the time. About foreign incursions into Indian territory. About growth rates, and migrant welfare, and expenditure, and PM CARES.

Second, stop marketing 20,000 lakh Crore packages as relief measures when in truth it comprises money already spent and money to be given as loans, and imaginary money that will never reach the people who need it.

Third, stop cheating the state governments of their dues, made through a constitutional promise. Stop wasting funds on your vanity projects, when the state governments – who actually make a difference in people’s lives and not just on television screens – need what is owed to them to govern.

We need to remember Hans Christian Andersen’s story, the Emperor’s New Clothes, where the emperor was clothed in nothing but his sycophantic courtiers did not tell him so. Bengali poet Nirendranath Chakravorty in his poem ‘Ulongo Raja’ quoted only a little innocent child in the entire kingdom who had the courage to ask the naked emperor – Raja tor kaapor koi? I too ask today – Emperor, Where are your clothes?

(Mahua Moitra is a Trinamool Congress MP from West Bengal. This article is adapted from excerpts from her speech in the Lok Sabha on September 19, 2020)
(IPA Service)